Astor Wines and Spirits is a New York institution that has translated its renowned brick-and-mortar expertise into a capable online store. The wine selection is excellent, with knowledgeable curation that spans everyday bottles to rare finds, and the spirits and sake collections are equally well-curated. The loyalty program rewards regulars, and staff picks and tasting notes add genuine editorial value that most online wine retailers lack. Free shipping at 125 dollars is a reasonable threshold for wine orders. The 14-day return window is tighter than average but understandable given the perishable nature of the product. Delivery at 3-7 days is standard for alcohol shipping. The main limitation is shipping restrictions to certain states. For wine enthusiasts who value expert curation over algorithmic recommendations, Astor is a standout choice.